What is the history behind the Vatican?

By Dr. Richard M. Swier, LTC U.S. Army (Ret.)

The Vatican: A History

Vatican City was not constructed by a single person or at a single point in time. Its development spans nearly two millennia, shaped by Roman emperors, Renaissance popes, and famous architects.

Key Figures in the Vatican’s Construction

Emperor Constantine (4th Century AD): Commissioned the original Old St. Peter’s Basilica around 318–326 AD over the traditional site of St. Peter’s tomb. This established the area as the center of Christianity in Rome.

The Renaissance Popes (15th–17th Centuries):

Pope Nicholas V: First conceived replacing the decaying ancient basilica in the mid-15th century.

Pope Julius II: Initiated the grand reconstruction project in 1506 by tearing down the old structure and laying the cornerstone for the modern St. Peter’s Basilica.

Pope Sixtus IV: Commissioned the construction of the Sistine Chapel in the 1470s.

 Master Architects and Artists:

Donato Bramante: Designed the original Greek-cross master plan for the new St. Peter’s Basilica.

Michelangelo: Designed the iconic massive central dome and painted the ceiling and altar wall of the Sistine Chapel.

Carlo Maderno: Extended the nave and designed the monumental front façade of St. Peter’s Basilica, completing the main structure in 1615.

Gian Lorenzo Bernini: Designed the grand St. Peter’s Square (the outer colonnades framing the basilica entrance), along with much of the interior Baroque art, including the monumental bronze Baldachin.

Political Establishment

While the physical buildings were constructed over centuries, Vatican City as an independent sovereign nation was officially created in 1929 through the Lateran Treaty, signed by Pope Pius XI and Italian Prime Minister Benito Mussolini.

The Vatican is two things at once—a place with 2,000 years of layered history, and a state that is one of the strangest political creations on Earth. Let’s untangle both.

The Place: Where It All Sits

The Vatican Hill (Vaticanus) sits on the west bank of the Tiber, outside the original boundaries of ancient Rome. In the pagan era it was a marginal area—used for cemeteries and, notably, a circus built by Caligula and Nero where Christians were executed.

  • Tradition holds that Saint Peter was martyred there around 64–67 AD under Nero and buried on the adjacent hill.
  • By the 2nd century, a modest shrine marked the site. This is the historical seed of everything that followed.

The Timeline

Early Christian & Imperial Era

  • ~320 AD: Emperor Constantine builds the first Old St. Peter’s Basilica over the presumed tomb.
  • The Bishop of Rome gradually claims primacy among Christian bishops—partly theological, partly because Rome was the imperial capital.

The Papal States (756–1870)

  • 756 AD: The Donation of Pepin gives the Pope temporal territory—the birth of the Papal States, a real kingdom spanning central Italy.
  • For over a thousand years the Pope was not just a spiritual leader but a monarch with armies, taxes, and courts.
  • This era includes the Crusades, the Inquisition, the Renaissance papacy (the Borgias, Julius II), and the commissioning of Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel ceiling.

The Renaissance Rebuild

  • 1506–1626: Old St. Peter’s is demolished and replaced by the current basilica—funded partly by indulgence sales, which helped spark the Protestant Reformation.
  • The Swiss Guard (1506) and the Vatican Library (1475) take shape in this period.

Collapse & the “Prisoner Pope” (1870–1929)

  • 1870: Italian unification seizes the Papal States. The Pope loses all territory and retreats into the Vatican as a self-declared “prisoner.”
  • The standoff lasts 59 years.

The Lateran Treaty (1929)

  • Mussolini and Pius XI sign the Lateran Treaty, creating the modern Vatican City State—the world’s smallest sovereign nation at ~0.49 km².
  • This is the legal founding of the Vatican as a country. It’s essentially a monarchical absolute state ruled by the Pope, with its own stamps, coins, media, and courts.

Why It Matters Beyond Religion

The Vatican is also a financial and diplomatic power, and this is where the institutional skepticism comes in:

  • The Vatican Bank (IOR) has a long, documented history of opaque dealings—the Banco Ambrosiano collapse in 1982, allegations of money laundering, and decades of reform pressure.
  • It maintains diplomatic relations with ~180 countries and functions as a major soft-power broker.
  • Its archives—released in controlled batches—have repeatedly shown the gap between public narrative and internal record.

The Core Takeaway

The Vatican is a case study in how spiritual authority and temporal power fused into a single institution. It survived the fall of Rome, the Reformation, the loss of its empire, and the rise of the modern nation-state—by adapting, rebranding, and holding its information close.

  • It is not just a church.
  • It is not just a country.
  • It is a 2,000-year-old institution that has outlasted nearly every rival it ever had—and it has always understood that control of the record is as important as control of the territory.

The Political Intrigue of the Vatican

The Vatican is, functionally, an absolute monarchy with an elected king—and any institution that combines absolute power with closed-door elections produces intrigue the way a swamp produces mosquitoes. Here’s the anatomy of it.

The Core Mechanism: Electing a King for Life

  • The College of Cardinals elects the Pope in a conclave—cardinals locked in the Sistine Chapel, no phones, no outside contact.
  • The Pope then rules until death or resignation (resignation being rare—Celestine V in 1294, Benedict XVI in 2013).
  • This means every power play is a long game: factions position for the next conclave years in advance.
  • The Curia—the Vatican’s bureaucratic apparatus—is where real day-to-day power lives. Control the Curia, and you can frustrate a Pope you can’t depose.

The Greatest Hits of Papal Intrigue

The Borgias (1492–1503)

  • Rodrigo Borgia becomes Alexander VI through what contemporaries openly described as bribery.
  • He made his own son—Cesare Borgia—a cardinal and then a military commander, carving out territory for the family.
  • The family’s grip on the papacy was so brazen that Machiavelli used Cesare as the model for The Prince.

The Cadaver Synod (897 AD)

  • Pope Stephen VI had his predecessor Formosus exhumed, dressed in papal robes, and put on trial—the corpse propped on a throne while charges were read.
  • The verdict was guilty; the body was stripped, mutilated, and dumped in the Tiber.
  • Stephen was later imprisoned and strangled. This is the Vatican’s political intrigue in its purest, most unhinged form.

The Western Schism (1378–1417)

  • Two—then three—men simultaneously claimed to be Pope, each with his own Curia, treasury, and backers (Rome, Avignon, and briefly Pisa).
  • It took a council to force a resolution, and it permanently damaged the papacy’s claim to unified authority.

The 2013 Resignation

  • Benedict XVI resigning—the first pope to do so in ~600 years—was a seismic political event.
  • The backdrop reportedly involved the VatiLeaks scandal: confidential documents leaked by a papal butler, exposing internal power struggles, corruption, and factional warfare inside the Curia.
  • What emerged publicly was a picture of a court divided into rival camps, each briefing against the other.

The Permanent Factions

Vatican politics isn’t left/right in the ordinary sense. It’s a set of recurring fault lines:

  • Reformers vs. Traditionalists — how much to modernize doctrine and governance.
  • Curialists vs. Outsiders — career bureaucrats vs. those the Pope brings in from outside.
  • Centralizers vs. National Churches — Rome’s authority vs. local bishops’ autonomy.
  • The Italian faction vs. everyone else — the Curia was Italian-dominated for centuries; internationalization is an ongoing fight.

Every Pope inherits this machinery and either co-opts, purges, or gets ground down by it.

Where Money and Power Meet

  • The IOR (Vatican Bank) scandals—Banco Ambrosiano, the 1982 death of Roberto Calvi found hanging under Blackfriars Bridge in London—are the intersection of finance, politics, and the Church.
  • These episodes show that the Vatican’s internal politics has never been purely theological. Money, reputations, and institutional survival are always in the room.

The Pattern

Strip away the ritual and the same logic appears every time:

  1. Absolute power + closed elections → factions form.
  2. Factions + no external accountability → leaks, purges, and scandals.
  3. Scandals + institutional survival instinct → controlled disclosure, quiet reshuffling, and the archive stays closed.

The Vatican has survived 2,000 years precisely because it is ruthlessly good at internal politics. The intrigue isn’t a bug—it’s the operating system.

©2026 . All rights reserved.